Cross-platform development is among the hottest topics in tech right now. More and more companies are choosing hybrid frameworks over native frameworks. Due to increasing demand, the cross-platform domain has seen a massive surge in the number of frameworks on the market. The more choices become available, the harder it is to determine which option is most appropriate for a given cross-platform development project.
Flutter and Xamarin are two of the most popular cross-platform development frameworks at the moment. Xamarin has been around for some time and has an air of maturity, while Flutter is a plucky up-and-comer backed by Google.
In this guide, we’ll take a deep dive into each of the two frameworks and then draw comparisons between them to help you choose the best one for your use case.
Here’s what we’ll cover:
- What is cross-platform development?
- What is Xamarin?
- What is Xamarin used for?
- Why use Xamarin?
- Limitations of using Xamarin
- What is Flutter?
- What is Flutter used for?
- Limitations of using Flutter
- Xamarin vs. Flutter: Which is better?
What is cross-platform development?
Cross-platform development refers to the process of building applications that can run on various platforms, such as Android, iOS, and web, using a common codebase and tech stack. This means that instead of creating multiple, platform-specific versions of your app, you are only required to write code once and deploy it on all platforms.
Among the greatest advantages to cross-platform development is the ability to write once and deploy anywhere. This helps you maintain uniformity across all versions of your application deployed across a wide range of platforms. Deploying on multiple platforms with a single codebase saves you time and resources. It also enhances the audience reach of your product since you can easily target customers on multiple platforms.
Most of the disadvantages associated with cross-platform app development revolve around performance and compatibility. The one-size-fits-all nature of cross-platform development limits your ability to take advantage of platform-specific opportunities to boost performance. It also prevents your app from accessing native features, which forces you to employ workarounds.
What is Xamarin?
Xamarin is an open-source, cross-platform development framework that was first founded in 2011. It allows you to create applications using C# that can run on multiple platforms without the need to port or rewrite code.
What is Xamarin used for?
Xamarin is useful in situations where code and business logic need to be shared across multiple platforms. Xamarin facilitates cross-platform application development using C# with Visual Studio.
In common language, Xamarin is a technology built upon the .NET legacy. Building applications in Xamarin is super easy if you have a basic understanding of how things in .NET and Visual Studio work. Unlike other cross-platform alternatives, such as Flutter, you don’t need to learn an entirely new programming language. This makes the process of creating prototypes and small cross-platform applications quick and simple.
Why use Xamarin?
How does Xamarin stack up against its cross-platform counterparts? The reasons to use Xamarin, as discussed above, are manifold, but let’s highlight a few distinct competitive advantages.
Applications built using Xamarin are known to exhibit native-like performance metrics. This is due to the excellent optimization in Xamarin’s API and the Xamarin team’s concerted effort to imitate native-like performance numbers.
Although it not a part of its initial release, Xamarin recently introduced hot reload to help you observe changes to your source code in real time. The addition of hot reload improves and accelerates the developer experience, enabling you to spend more time perfecting the nuts and bolts of your Xamarin applications.
Xamarin offers an unmatched ecosystem of development frameworks to build applications of all sorts. With C#, .NET, and Xamarin on Microsoft Visual Studio, you are set to design stellar cross-platform products.
The Xamarin.Forms API allows you to take advantage of Xamarin’s standard interface elements to help reuse your code across various platforms. If you need finer customization, you can use Xamarin.iOS and Xamarin.Android for more tailored, platform-specific designs.
Free to use
Xamarin is an open-source, free-to-use framework. This means you can easily set up your new project in Xamarin without having to worry about any costs related to the framework and coding environment.
Limitations of using Xamarin
As much as there is to love about Xamarin, you should be aware of a few limitations associated with using the framework.
When the Xamarin team introduces new platform features, it usually takes time for the updates to reflect in the Xamarin tools. This can create hurdles in the development process and diminish the developer experience.
Large app size
Due to their cross-platform nature, Xamarin apps can take up to around 5–10 MBs of extra size on release versions of applications. This can lead to increased storage load for your end users.
Building applications with complex user interfaces can get tricky with Xamarin because customizing UIs to platforms introduces a lot of platform-specific customization. Sometimes, this largely defeats the purpose of building cross-platform codebases.
To fit platform-specific standards, you may encounter situations where you’re forced to customize your codebase for each platform. This can introduce unnecessary efforts in gaining basic knowledge of managing platform-specific languages, such as Kotlin and Java for Android and Swift and Objective-C for iOS, to understand and get the most out of the platform-specific APIs offered by Xamarin.
What is Flutter?
Flutter is an open-source, cross-platform application development framework created by Google in 2018. It is designed to give developers an easy-to-use cross-platform development interface as well as optimize performance for users. Flutter has been known to achieve true native-like performance on modern devices. It can also be adapted to publish performant applications on the web.
What is Flutter used for?
Flutter is particularly useful for building mobile applications to run on Android and iOS at the same time. Flutter uses Dart as its programming language. The combination of Dart and Flutter offers great portability with the source code. Flutter hangs its hat on excellent performance and a great developer experience.
Popular applications built with Flutter include:
- Google Ads
- Google Pay
- Alibaba Group
Why use Flutter?
Flutter is the hottest newcomer in the cross-platform industry. Let’s highlight a handful of the myriad reasons to choose Flutter for your next big project.
Shallow learning curve
Flutter is much easier to learn than many other cross-platform frameworks because it focuses on keeping the codebase as simple as possible. In the process, it gets rid of a lot of boilerplate.
One of the biggest reasons why Flutter has drawn a lot of attention is that it’s super fast. The hot reload feature enables you to make changes to your source code and observe the changes in near-real time on your test device. This makes the development process much better aligned than on other frameworks.
With ahead-of-time (AOT) compilation, Flutter can fairly claim to match true nativelike performance metrics. Its unmatched code reusability and performance make Flutter a perfect cross-platform framework for large projects.
Free to use
As with other open-source frameworks, Flutter is free to use.
Limitations of using Flutter
While Flutter offers excellent benefits, especially in terms of performance, it also introduces some drawbacks, including bloated code and lack of support for certain libraries and platforms. Let’s zoom in on some of the disadvantages associated with Flutter app development.
Large app size
As with all other cross-platform frameworks, Flutter comes with a lot of baggage. The ability to run on multiple platforms comes at the cost of increased application file size.
Lack of third-party libraries
Another important drawback of writing applications in Flutter is that there are relatively few community-generated libraries designed for use with the framework. This is due in large part to the fact that Flutter is one of the newest technologies on the market.
Flawed iOS support
Since Flutter is a Google product, it is naturally inclined toward the Android side of things. Support for iOS is secondary and therefore often filled with issues.
Xamarin vs. Flutter: Which is better?
Now that you have a good idea of how Xamarin and Flutter stack up individually, it’s finally time to compare Xamarin vs. Flutter.
We’ll evaluate Xamarin vs. Flutter according to the following criteria:
- Development languages
- Code reuse
- Support and ecosystem
Cross-platform frameworks tend to take a major hit in application performance when compared to their native counterparts. That’s why it’s important to evaluate the performance difference so that you’re not compromising the user experience for cross-platform portability.
As we have been emphasizing throughout the article, Flutter is known to perform extremely well compared to almost all contemporary cross-platform frameworks due to its intelligent ahead-of-time compilation strategy.
Due to its superior maturity, Xamarin is used across a wider range of projects than Flutter. However, according to StackOverflow’s “2020 Developer Survey,” Flutter is much more loved than Xamarin, with a staggering 68.8 percent of developers expressing interest in developing applications with Flutter.
Xamarin is no slouch in this category, either, given that 45.4 percent of respondents are interested in Xamarin.
Anytime you need to learn a new development language to start using a new framework, it adds to the learning curve. If a framework requires you to learn a radically new language that has little to no use outside of the framework, you might want to think twice before investing your time into it.
Xamarin uses .NET languages, such as C# and F#. These are popular languages that have several use cases outside of Xamarin. This makes it worth your while to invest time and resources into learning these languages. Upskilling in C#, in particular, will open a lot of doors for you as a developer.
Along with adding a learning curve for developers, Dart also poses lock-in situations. Learning Dart will only benefit you in the context of Flutter development. In the ever-changing industrial market, it’s worth considering whether you want to sink the time into learning Dart at all.
Flutter comes packed with some great collections of UI components, both in Material and Cupertino. This makes the developer experience a breeze and eliminates the need to worry about styling your application.
On the other hand, Xamarin.Forms offers a detailed cross-platform UI toolkit consisting of UI components that look and feel like native components but can be used in a cross-platform setup. Once you’re set to use them in your app, these components are compiled down to their in-platform variants. If you’re looking to gain more control over how your app looks, you can try out Xamarin.iOS or Xamarin.Android.
Both frameworks are neck-in-neck when it comes to component support. You can’t go wrong with either Flutter or Xamarin.
Code reuse is a fundamental feature of cross-platform application development. As such, it’s a crucial factor to consider when deciding on a cross-platform development framework.
Flutter allows you to write common code for both platforms, but it also has a lot of room for platform-specific differences. This means you have to write a lot of platform-specific code for your Flutter application to work well on all platforms.
On the other hand, Xamarin prides itself on allowing developers to reuse up to 90 percent of their application code. With packages like Xamarin.Form, Xamarin makes code sharing a breeze.
Both technologies are free to use and their source code is available openly.
Support and ecosystem
When deciding between two frameworks, it is important to consider the community support. This includes learning resources for beginners, a common place for developers to discuss issues and ideas, and more.
Flutter has one of the strongest communities out of all frameworks and languages built around it. The Google docs are extremely beginner-friendly and there is a huge amount of content available on public sites and forums such as StackOverflow to look for help on demand.
Community support for Xamarin is more limited. While Microsoft does provide some free Xamarin courses and learning paths to help you get started, the level of content is not up to Flutter’s standards.
Cross-platform frameworks are a delight to work with. The ability to ship code that can run on more than one platform easily is more powerful than you can imagine until you experience it. For businesses, cross-platform tools can help you establish a foothold in multiple domains without going through much hassle.
When it comes to choosing the right framework for you, it’s important to understand your requirements and goals. Xamarin is one of the oldest horses in the cross-platform race, while Flutter is relatively new to the game. Xamarin brings a lot of benefits associated with a mature framework, but Flutter manages to keep up with its strong community-focused approach.
The best cross-platform framework for your development project will always depend on your use case and the goals and requirements of your project. But if pressed to choose one over the other, I would give Flutter a slight edge over Xamarin.
Flutter’s rising popularity, ever-increasing support of libraries and tools, native-like performance, and huge community are just a few reasons why you should consider building your next cross-platform app with Flutter.
LogRocket: Full visibility into your web apps
LogRocket is a frontend application monitoring solution that lets you replay problems as if they happened in your own browser. Instead of guessing why errors happen, or asking users for screenshots and log dumps, LogRocket lets you replay the session to quickly understand what went wrong. It works perfectly with any app, regardless of framework, and has plugins to log additional context from Redux, Vuex, and @ngrx/store.