If you’ve ever worked in or around startups, you’ve definitely seen it: a small team, new funding, great enthusiasm, and a whiteboard full of objectives and key results (OKRs). Everything appears polished, strategic, and “grown-up.” However, for early-stage products, the polish might be a trap.
In the early, messy, uncertain stages of product development, narrative always outperforms strategy. A compelling story not only guides your team, but it also persuades investors, early adopters, and potential hires to believe in something that doesn’t exist yet. Strategy and OKRs have their uses, but they’re tools for increasing clarity, not creating it.
This article explores why early-stage products should prioritize storytelling over a rigid goal-setting framework. It goes on to demonstrate how a compelling narrative can attract investors and encourage early adopters, while also outlining when to transition into structured strategies as the product matures.
Many early-stage startups fall into the trap of acting like big organizations before they have anything to scale. They create quarterly OKRs, establish acquisition, and conduct “data-driven experiments” without a steady stream of customers to examine.
Here’s what generally occurs:
Take a small startup that establishes an ambitious OKR: “Acquire 5,000 users by Q1.”
The problem with this is that they haven’t figured out why people would use their product in the first place. Every meeting devolves into a metric debate, and morale drops when targets are consistently missed. They didn’t need additional optimization, they needed a unified story about why the product was important.
Now, let’s compare that to teams that start with a story. Consider this simple narrative: “We help remote teams feel like they’re in the same room.” This is way more more effective than any early growth target because it:
Narratives work because they can convey meaning in ways that numbers cannot. In the early phases, most numbers are too little to matter. However, a compelling story can outperform its weight, changing perceptions and opening doors that mere statistics cannot yet support.
Your story and strategy are both important, but their roles vary depending on the stage of a product’s development.
The story is what drives the early days. It instills belief, explains why the product is important, and provides your team, investors, and early adopters with something to rally around. At this point, most statistics are less meaningful. Your story bridges the gap by triggering emotional responses and providing a vision of the future.
Strategy and OKRs, on the other hand, become relevant once that belief is established. They focus on coordinating execution, monitoring progress, and scaling what already works. OKRs are great for keeping larger teams on track and optimizing existing systems.
The danger comes when they’re applied too early. The story answers the question, “Why should anyone care?” Strategy answers, “How do we get there consistently?”
You need both, but they need to arrive at the right time. Without a story, strategy risks becoming hollow. Without a strategy, the story risks staying vague and ungrounded.
OKRs and structured strategies will eventually become important. The trick is understanding when to make that transition. Moving too soon suffocates your narrative. Move too late, and chaos ensues.
This practical checklist could be used to determine if it’s time to go from story-first to strategy-driven:
If two or more of these are true, it’s time to start layering in OKRs. Until then, keep leaning on the story.
To demonstrate how narrative can drive traction in the early stages, let’s explore two well-known success stories: Airbnb and Figma, and how each company’s emphasis on storytelling generated momentum before strategy took over.
Airbnb started in 2007 when its founders rented out air mattresses to cover rent. At the time, “people paying to stay in strangers’ homes” was almost absurd:
The narrative: Instead of focusing on early growth metrics, the founders rallied around the idea of “belonging anywhere.” They positioned Airbnb not as a booking site, but as a new way of experiencing the world.
The impact: This narrative appealed to both early adopters and investors. Users who were initially suspicious about “couch surfing 2.0” were instead drawn to the larger notion of connection and belonging. Investors invested not because of the hockey stick graphs, but because they believed in the story.
Transition: After the platform gained traction and the team grew, Airbnb added OKRs for trust, supply, and booking volume, but only after the story had established the brand.
Key takeaways:
Figma entered a crowded design tool market dominated by Adobe and Sketch. It was late to the game and had no right to win on features alone:
The narrative: Figma offered a story of collaboration rather than direct competition with Adobe. Its message is: “Design should be multiplayer.” This was more than just tools; it was about a new style of working.
The impact: That story spread organically. Designers frustrated with file-sharing and version conflicts instantly understood the value. Early adopters championed the product because it matched their lived frustrations. Investors saw a clear wedge into the market.
Transition: When usage skyrocketed, Figma introduced OKRs for enterprise adoption, integrations, and infrastructure expansion. However, the narrative of multiplayer design remained vital even as the company grew.
Key takeaways:
Of course, not every startup gets this balance right. Everpix and Webvan are reminders of what can go wrong when metrics and optimization overshadow narrative and early user connection.
Everpix was a photo startup that automatically organized users’ images. The product was beautifully designed and technically strong.
The team obsessed over polish, features, and metrics such as engagement. However, they failed to tell a clear story about why people should use it over free or familiar alternatives (like Apple Photos). Despite positive reviews and a small but loyal user base, Everpix couldn’t grow fast enough to sustain itself. Investors pulled back, citing unclear positioning and a lack of difference.
Instead of evolving into a stronger story about emotional value (memories, relationships), Everpix focused more on product polish and eventually shut down in 2013.
Webvan, a dotcom-era grocery delivery service, raised nearly $800M and scaled aggressively in the late 1990s.
The company was focused on aggressive expansion metrics, launching cities, building warehouses, and meeting growth targets. However, it never addressed the essential question: Why would customers prefer Webvan over traditional food shopping?
Expansion had overtaken adoption. Costs skyrocketed while users lagged. By 2001, Webvan had declared bankruptcy, becoming one of the most memorable dotcom collapses. It introduced a large-scale strategy and optimization before proving the narrative with early users.
Your story isn’t just fluff when it comes to early-stage products — it’s necessary for survival. Although numbers can be motivating, they start out insignificant and can take a long time to scale. What people remember, repeat, and unite around is your story.
Airbnb and Figma demonstrate that story-driven companies can captivate hearts long before spreadsheets. On the other hand, Everpix and Webvan demonstrate that pursuing optimization too early can lead to failure, no matter how well-funded or polished the product.
The lesson here is to begin with a narrative, then layer in strategy when it’s appropriate. Because, in the early stages, a great narrative not only outperforms OKRs but also supports them later.
Featured image source: IconScout
LogRocket identifies friction points in the user experience so you can make informed decisions about product and design changes that must happen to hit your goals.
With LogRocket, you can understand the scope of the issues affecting your product and prioritize the changes that need to be made. LogRocket simplifies workflows by allowing Engineering, Product, UX, and Design teams to work from the same data as you, eliminating any confusion about what needs to be done.
Get your teams on the same page — try LogRocket today.
Learn how to prepare and launch internal products effectively with real PM examples, readiness pillars, and a practical launch checklist.
Learn how to balance confidence and collaboration as a product leader while building trust, authenticity, and high-performing teams.
Data shows you what users do, not why. Learn how blending qualitative and quantitative insights fuels real product innovation.
Feeling overwhelmed by endless PM tasks? Learn simple, proven strategies to stay organized, focused, and in control of your workload.
Learn more →
