Alexander Solovyev
Nov 1, 2022 ⋅ 9 min read

Learn React Portals by example

Alexander Solovyev Frontend developer and mentor @mkdev.me

Recent posts:

Understanding Solid Js Props A Complete Guide From Beginner To Advanced

Understanding SolidJS props: A complete guide

Let’s see how SolidJS props work to promote component reusability, exploring basic to advanced concepts for a complete understanding.

Temitope Oyedele
Dec 7, 2023 ⋅ 11 min read
Eleventy Vs. Next.js Static-Site Generation

Eleventy vs. Next.js for static site generation

We evaluate Eleventy and Next.js and compare both static site generators in terms of performance, developer experience, scalability, and ecosystem.

Nelson Michael
Dec 7, 2023 ⋅ 11 min read
Build Full-Stack App React Goxygen

Build a full-stack app with React and Goxygen

We show how to use Goxgen to scaffold a full-stack React app. See how to integrate React with Go and modify Goxygen to suit your project requirements.

Clara Ekekenta
Dec 6, 2023 ⋅ 8 min read
Express Js Adoption Guide Overview Examples Alternatives

Express.js adoption guide: Overview, examples, and alternatives

Express.js is a Node.js framework for creating maintainable and fast backend web applications in JavaScript. In the fast-paced world of […]

Antonello Zanini
Dec 6, 2023 ⋅ 17 min read
View all posts

8 Replies to "Learn React Portals by example"

  1. I observed a problem in this and I thought it’s important to notify, else a lot of other people might make the same mistake.

    In the `Portal` component, you are using `useEffect` with `el` and `mount` as dependencies and that actually causes unnecessary re-renders even if the prop(children in this case) of the Portal component hasn’t changed. Meaning if there is any change in the parent component which isn’t related to the Portal also, the Portal gets re-rendered.

    example:Try adding say a state variable `count` in the parent component and change the value when the modal is shown, although there is no change in portal, it would still re-render the portal which is bad.

    One Solution is to move the `mount` and `el` outside the Portal component. This still re-renders the Portal but it doesn’t mount the portal content again which would trigger useEffect otherwise as its not a new instance of either `el` or `mount`.

    Other solution would be to use the class component. But please be careful when you are demonstrating something with hooks. I think we underestimate the complexity of the hooks in most cases, and in the end we shoot in our own foot.

  2. @Brihaspati thanks for feedback. Yes, I confirm that my implementation of Portal is naive and could be improved for performance.

    Instead of just moving the el and mount outside of the component there is also an option to use some of the React hooks that keep variables between renders, for example, useRef:
    import { useEffect, useRef, memo } from “react”;
    import { createPortal } from “react-dom”;

    const Portal = ({ children }) => {
    * keeps ref between renders
    const el = useRef(null);

    * create element if empty (for the first time render only)
    if (!el.current) el.current = document.createElement(“div”);

    useEffect(() => {
    const mount = document.getElementById(“portal-root”);
    const { current } = el;

    return () => mount.removeChild(current);
    }, []); // no dependencies to avoid rerenders

    return createPortal(children, el.current);

    export default memo(Portal);
    here is a live demo for it https://codesandbox.io/s/portal-with-hooks-70pyc

    You could also check other possible implementations of React Portal with hooks in this stackoverflow thread: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/53595935/how-can-i-make-react-portal-work-with-react-hook

  3. Hi! I was curious why we need the “el” to be appended? I tried with directly appending to the mount point in the DOM and it works as well. Does the “el” pattern help with something I am not seeing?

  4. Hi Muhammad, the el pattern is used for enabling the option of multiple portal items on the page: each portal appends its own element to the portal mount point. That might be helpful, for example, if there are multiple small popups on the page that should be kept open at the same time

  5. There’s an issue when the portal rerenders because the portal element is removed and rappended inside the useEffect hook, there’s no portal element to render to so the portal’s children content is absent. I fixed this by replacing the useEffect hook with useLayoutEffect to block react until the portal is rendered. Fortunately this is unnecessary if you instead store the portal element between rerenders like what is done above.

  6. I found a flaw following this implementation approach, which is that when the button is in the local scrolling area, clicking the button opens the tips. When scrolling, the tips will not follow. Using global scrolling does not have this problem because the tips do not scroll relative to the body

Leave a Reply