2023-04-06
1980
#css#react
Eslam Hefnawy
17834
Apr 6, 2023 ⋅ 7 min read

SCSS vs. styled-components: Advantages and caveats

Eslam Hefnawy Serverless Architect at Serverless, Inc. Co-creator of the Serverless Framework and the lead architect of Serverless Components.

Recent posts:

Exploring Actions And Request Rewriting In Astro

Exploring actions and request rewriting in Astro

Astro v4.8 ships with server actions and request rewriting. Let’s see how to use these long-awaited (though still experimental) features.

Ivaylo Gerchev
Jul 17, 2024 ⋅ 13 min read
Comparing Fiber Vs Gin For Go Web Development

Comparing Fiber vs. Gin for Go web development

Go Fiber and Gin are two popular Go frameworks that provide extensive toolkits for developing high-performance apps with modern features.

Temitope Oyedele
Jul 17, 2024 ⋅ 8 min read
Leveraging Typescript Branded Types For Stronger Type Checks

Leveraging TypeScript branded types for stronger type checks

Branded types in TypeScript allow us to write code more clearly, provide more type-safe solutions, and maintain our code more efficiently.

Rashedul Alam
Jul 16, 2024 ⋅ 5 min read
Zoneless Change Detection In Angular 18

Zoneless change detection in Angular 18

Angular v18 introduced an experimental feature called zoneless change detection, eliminating the need for Zone.js.

Yan Sun
Jul 15, 2024 ⋅ 5 min read
View all posts

6 Replies to "SCSS vs. styled-components: Advantages and caveats"

  1. “Since styled-components don’t come with any globally scoped selectors, you don’t need to worry about conflicts and styles overwriting each other. Although Sass comes with nice upgrades such as nesting and variables, it’s more likely to lead to overwriting styles.”

    Well. You are comparing oranges and apples here. If you would use scss using css modules and not using them as a globally available stylesheet then this would not be a problem. E.g instead of importing using `import ‘/.styles.scss’` you would import using “import styles from ‘./styles.module.scss” and then apply the styles to the elements using …. Besides. Using styled-component makes your code highly dependent on a specific framework. Css modules can be used with css, sass, less etc.

  2. I think this article horribly underplays the downside of mixing all the styles together. if you look at this trivial example, the “wrapper” class has 8 properties. Now imagine passing this through a couple of libraries each adding a couple of overrides, and for something simple that sets a position and font you end up with ~50 properties most of which override each other. This chain is impossible to debug (by design) because you can’t trace it back without looking through every component in the hierarchy. And when you get to start using style merging and the tree for your component style has dozens of nodes, it becomes infeasible to fix CSS anymore and leads to rewrites.

    The “benefit” of not listing the flat list of class names like class=”one two three … fifteen” is that you end up with one class:

    .merged {
    one.prop1,
    one.prop2,

    fifteen.propSecondToLast,
    fifteen.propLast,
    }

    except without pointers back to the original classes.

    This article mentions that “legacy” websites have more SCSS. Well… it’s a better solution and styled-components codebases just haven’t been around long enough to evolve into ugly behemoths, but it’s only a matter of time.

  3. At work, we use styled components in all of our non-trivial React projects. The codebases are large (some millions of lines of code), and it is very easy to reason about the styles — the projects are certainly not “ugly behemoths”. I used to use Sass/SCSS in my personal projects and have since moved to styled components for the productivity increase and cleanliness. Your comment appears more naive and hurtful than useful to the discussion. Mind you, I think Sass is awesome — I would still use it for any non-React project.

  4. If js is single thread, and dynamic css in NOT ‘a head of time’ vs SCSS.
    Plus injecting dynamic css cause browser repaint.
    Is it worthwhile?

Leave a Reply